Received the book directly from the author of the novel for a honest review.
First Impression – I was not satisfied with the title and the cover, as it resembled more of a sex position to me (Am I so corrupted?) nevertheless, just being honest. The font was way too smaller which made reading a bit difficult, could have been better. The paper quality was good thought.
Overall Impression – The blurb anticipated my expectation but the story didn’t match it as such. The author has a good style and diction, the way the story flows and her way of handling the knowledge is good for a debut. Though, the story didn’t resonate with me as much as the blurb did. The initial character introduction for about 18 pages could have been cut short, and there were various other redundancies as well which could have been tightened with a good beta-reader.
The negatives make the book a skimming read than a line-by-line read. With the capability the author has, if she picks a better plot and a storyline that reveals a few twists, I think it would be a super win. There were a few instances which were abnormal, but had no cushioning details to accompany. To call a person the dream man would actually take a lot, the character falling for someone so older for age and few other details didn’t fit it and also, didn’t help the story to take any twist.
Being a writer, the way the protagonist feels bad for manuscript rejections were something that one could feel closer to, still the same could have been explored much more with realistic details.
Rating: 2.5 / 5
Wow factors: 1) Simple language 2) Diction 3) Style
Frown factors: 1) Storyline was not up to the mark 2) Lengthier for the context with redundant details
Looking forward to read a even better book from the author.
First Impression – I was excited when I read about the author, for the list of awards and recognition she has received. It did made me raise my brows initially. I was disappointed with the quality of the paperback, it made reading difficult. I was not impressed with the cover image or the title either; I started reading with the author’s esteemed position in mind.
Received this book via the book club in return for an honest review, The book has 12 short stories that are based on issues faced by women and has time as a parameter through which the travel of each story is weaved.
Genre – Women fiction, short stories
Overall Impression – Stories were good, the kind of emotional play attempted and the struggle a few women go through is explored pretty well. I didn’t get the total punch of emotions hitting me hard, but the stories were bit predictable, and that being the reason, I found the stories bit lengthier as well.
The stories revolve around important issues that are to be considered, be it the education and career a woman should possess, the kind of empowerment required and the sexual awareness necessary to at least know what is happening to one as a kid, is properly explored yet not pretty powerful as expected.
Wow Factors: 1) Issues involved 2) Simple and lucid language
Frown factors: 1) the quality of the paperback, the author should consider the right publishers next time. 2) Diction and phrases could have been better; it was more like a essay than a story. The necessary word play and quality of dialogues were missing big time.
Recently, I happened to attend the book launch of Author Ravi Subramanian, and during the Q&A session when we asked about self-publishing and vanity publishing, he said “According to the recent research and statistics only 72 copies get sold on an average of a newbie Indian author among which 60 are bought by their own friends,” which is absolutely true in most of the cases.
Let’s take a sneak at the vanity publishing industry for instance:
I recently saw a video where a lady ties her cows near a temple, and sells fodder for those who visit the temple to buy and feed the cow. She owns the cows, she gets the fodder from her own garden, and though it is her duty to feed her cows she makes it her business model to make money, to feed her cows and also makes money selling the cow’s milk.
In vanity publishing,
Cow – your manuscript
Fodder – your money
Those who buy fodder to feed the cow – your friends who buys the book for you
Cow’s milk – Publisher’s profit
If you want me to be brutally honest, I would also say that you get the cow dung – Royalty.
Do you know? The vanity publishers feel damn shy to shout out loud that they are vanity publishers, they hide their identity with a term “self-publishing book platform”
What prompted me to write this post? – well the picture below
I had a few bad experiences during my transition from a novice writer to the person I am who knows the sad truth about the publishing industry.
If I were the one who talks without giving it a second thought, soon after reading that message, I would have replied:
How on Earth you call your book a best seller?
Who the F*** gave you the liberty to give it a tag like that?
Who published your sick book?
How much did you pay for those fake reviews?
I would actually go on and on. Most of these fall under the filthy rich, the sick who sucked in love and failed miserably, the I want to become famous greed bitten imbeciles. I would be more than happy to meet someone who doesn’t fall under this category, but unfortunately almost 60% of those sick newbies who Facebook search the word “Author”, join all the writers-authors related groups and add the authors available fall in this category.
The most disgusting part is the fake reviews and fake ratings! Worst? – Yes buying 100 copies of their own book on amazon to get a better rating. A few newbie authors want to be the “best seller” but none focuses on building a readership. A few wants the word “Author” before their name but are really not. A few just wants pictures by their friends holding the book on their timeline but don’t care a damn whether they read. And the best of all, a few claim that it is absolutely okay to publish a book with grammatical mistakes – do you have an answer for a person who would pick a book to enhance their grammatical skills? What if you teach the worst to them? – Why are you not ready to spend on a good editor than on marketing? All you want is a search result with 10 different links talking about you but are you really worth it, who on Earth would actually Google your name? Grow up!
There are a few who stick reading to authors outside India pointing out the miserably failed so called best-sellers. I don’t have an answer, being an author is painful, the tag is burdening.
I am not trying to pull down anyone here, am not offended by what you do but please aren’t we responsible to take Indian literature to the next level?
Please stop publishing your college love stories, your school encounters, making out with your friend’s girlfriend, etc.. Oh yeah, I hear you, who am I to say that? right! But please what are you actually giving back to the world? Your novel will have your name inscribed even after you. Do you really want to write a book that has a bit of sex, a sucking love story, a super stupid conversation over a coffee, an unnecessary accident, an uncalled for betrayal et al. All these stories are taken, these are said – please stop! Stop writing your teenage stories.
I would like to thank the Indian authors who don’t fall under any of the or most of the or many of these categories.
I repeat that this post is not to hurt anyone or even about anyone in particular. Am just another author but not a best seller, and my book is not one of the bestselling. At least, forget that am an author – as the one who reads and reviews books day in and out, I very well know the standards of the Indian books that are getting published. I respect the authors who have written good stories, and my reviews are honest indeed.
Please write a good story, take the traditional publishing route or self-publish by yourself. Please don’t spend your or your parent’s hard earned money to vanity publish. (I did vanity publish, as I had no leads to follow, I was ignorant about the traditional and self-publishing route) Please ask for mentoring from a proper author rather than blindly spending on vanity publishing.
I just wanted to plead the others not to run behind the tag or fame.
God save the industry, please!
About me and my debut: I self-published my debut novella via a vanity-publishing firm as I was ignorant enough to understand how waste of a money it was and that I missed my chance of using other publishing ways, I thought I should write this post.
My debut is not a best-seller, but a good book. I don’t throw my book’s cover time and again asking my friends to buy – I keep writing and I am building my readership. I don’t have good grammatical skills and diction – but I employ a good editor as I feel responsible.
I organized a meet for aspiring writers in Chennai to help them understand the pitfalls in the publishing industry as well.
If this post by chance hurts you or your ideology – please pardon me!
I hereby end my rant.
Months back at my office premises when I had to perform a standup comedy for a few minutes, I said, “you know what I imagined when I started writing a book? It would be like Writer-Author-Book Reviewer-Public Speaker-Host-VJ-celebrity but then in reality what I actually happened to do was to write leave letters for my friends.”
But then, life has its own way of swinging a magical wand that conspires what you actually wanted to do. On a busy or rather lazy work day, as usual, I was texting my fellow CBC buddies on whatsapp. Bragadeesh Prasanna – admin of the Chennai bloggers club pinged me asking if I would “Host” a book launch event, I sent him a ‘roll-my-eyes’ smiley but then I was happy that something that I wanted to do came my way. Though my command over language and grammar slips when it comes to accent as a student from an Anglo Indian board school, I can pull it off easily.
When he told that the event is for Author Shikha Kumar who is coming down to Chennai to launch her second book “Logically stupid, that’s love,” I was all thrilled.
The next week, I was busy getting to know more about Shikha, her first book, the reviews and the list of questions to ask.
Being an ambivert, I can only talk and mingle with people that I can feel comfortable with, right now in my life after a few close friends who knows me in and out, it is my CBC buddies with whom I find some congenial company.
Though I had my own set of questions to ask when I met shikha kumar, the bloggers and I started questioning her one after the other based on the conversation.
It was great to hear how she accidentally turned an author, she stated “Reading a few best sellers, I thought, I can write much better than these folks,”
To see the stubborn shade of Shikha when she explained how choosy she is with the title, cover, publication and the indulgence of editor was indeed inspiring. She also said she is happy with the traditional route of publishing when I asked her about self-publishing as a better choice. A few of us also grabbed copies of her book as an autographed copy is worth much more right? She is one author I look up at when it comes to marketing the book the right way and with her second she has taken another great step with Book tours in the major cities of India.
I also had the opportunity to give a video review of her book with what I read, though a detailed review would follow in my blog.
Here are a few pictures from the event!
Wishing all the very best to Shikha on behalf of the Chennai bloggers club, thanks for choosing us to help you with the book tour. You can connect with Shikha here or through her website.
I would also like to thank Bragadeesh Prasanna, Mahesh Lakshmanan and Sindhu JP – admins of the Chennai bloggers group for providing me the opportunity to host this event. If you’re looking for a blog tour or brand positioning, you can reach the admins through the website.
Received the e-book from the book club in exchange for an honest review, and here you go! Mythology is my recent addiction and I am falling in love with that genre, and this book added more fuel to my greed of reading more mythology. Awe-struck is an understatement!
Genre – Mythology
First Impression – pretty cover that attracts instantly and the blurb just pulls you to read the book. And the very first word that you read is “Death” – “Death is hot” which makes the reader raise their brows with a smile. A very promising impression which says, “Am the book that you should read,” and yes, kept up till the end.
Overall Impression – One of the best books I have read in the recent times. This is the first book that painted a beautiful camouflage of Gods and ancient India with the modern world. It was enchanting and a fresh read which is powerful and believable, than the normal movies that portray God walking down the street or ordering a pizza types which though funny doesn’t touch you. Soul warrior is a show-stealer. I loved the thought process of the author Falguni and the way she handled the freedom to write a story that gives food for imagination. Not many authors attempt it.
What did I love about the book? 1) The extremely convincing blend of modern India and mythology characters 2) Falguni’s humour sprinkles that makes one smile ear to ear
Wow Factors: 1) Diction – best choice of words ever 2) Editor has done a commendable job
Frown Factors: 1) Pace dropped at a few points, 2) Descriptions fell short as well, either it was too much to take or related, am unable to decipher